Oreo® Ice Cream Sandwich = 3 PointsPlus®. A double-stuffed Oreo is 2 PointsPlus® so this is quite a deal considering how much bigger it is and how many points other “real” (i.e., not “diet”) ice cream treats are.
Vanilla “single” at Shake Shack = 6 PointsPlus ®with or without the cone. The chocolate is 8, so not quite as good a deal, but considering the size, it’s not too bad. The vanilla is probably the best “splurge” points deal I’ve found (again, because of its size). It’s not huge of course, but compared to three squares of chocolate for the same points value, it’s a lot more filling.
Snickers Ice Cream Bar = 5 PointsPlus®
Starbucks Lite Vanilla Frappuccino with Skim, without Whipped Cream (16 oz) = 5 PointsPlus®
Milka milk chocolate square = 1 PointsPlus®. This is the only square of chocolate I’ve found that’s less than 2 PointsPlus®. It’s European chocolate to boot (i.e. it’s amazing)!